SayIt

  • Home
  • Speakers
  • Speeches

2019-09-18 Meeting with Dr. Todd Lowary

  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    You met my colleague, Mario Pinto.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    That’s right.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    He suggested that I reach out to you to talk more about what you do as Digital Minister. I’m not naive enough to think that I can make that big of a difference, but one of the things I would like to do as part of working in Taiwan is to help the international community understand what’s so special about Taiwan and to try to help attract professionals to the Taiwanese workforce.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yeah, it goes both ways.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I’m really trying to be, to some degree, a foreign ambassador for Taiwan. If there’s ways I can help, then I’d be happy to do that.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yeah, I went and visited, I think, let’s see, Vancouver and Toronto and also I think Ottawa for two times already. That’s in the past year alone.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I do see that we share many common values in that we seem to not be so acutely aware that we share some very common values. That is the part that I would really like to introduce because in Taiwan, nowadays, like with President Tsai’s agenda of not just marriage equality but also transitional justice but also about all the sort of different reforms, it turns out that our issues, social issues, are very compatible, actually.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We also have mining rights with indigenous lines and how to meaningfully consult with the indigenous nations. It turns out, you’re having the same problem, sorry, same challenge.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Yeah.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    A lot of solutions is common between the two societies. We should really build that social relationship aside from the existing trade, economic, and ecological ones.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right. What’s your portfolio, then?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I’m the digital minister in charge of social innovation, open government, and youth engagement.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    As for digital transformation, that is not a job of any single ministry, right?

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Hence, my office is one delegate from each ministry. We have 32 vertical ministers, and they can each send one volunteer. Joel here is from MOFA, the foreign service delegate.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see, OK.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    One volunteer to my office…Then, my office represents different values because every ministry is, by its nature, a different value. We don’t allow two or more people from one ministry at the same time. I hear the MOVAQ is maybe a dozen people now, right?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Then, we make sure that we work out loud meaning that whatever project they’re working on, they do separate themselves. I don’t score or rank them. I don’t give assignments. If they have incompatible values, for example, the environmental one and the economic one, that’s the common one or the science innovation one with the social justice one, that’s another common one, and then we can figure out ways to openly collaborate.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We do this through e-petition. That’s a common source. Each ministry now also have a team called participation officers in charge of tackling emerging issues. They can also raise issues to my office. That’s the second one. Also, our youth counselors, which are reverse mentors to each minister, they can also suggest one. That’s our three incoming sources.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, I see. You’re in charge of then providing solutions to a variety of challenges.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    That’s right. My work is that of, I don’t know, philosophical work. I think everybody’s sides. I visit the rural indigenous areas. I live with people here, and then make their listening scalable and also make sure that the 12 different ministries also listen to them through tele presence while I’m in the indigenous or rural places.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    In Taiwan, we say meeting someone face to face builds 30 percent of trust, and so meeting through high-bandwidth tele presence may be 20 percent of trust. The importance here is that it’s entirely horizontal. They don’t need their minister’s approval to figure out solutions together.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Previously, it’s always the minister’s credit but it’s always the public servant’s fault. In a horizontal way, it’s the other way around. It’s readily transparent. It’s always their credit, and if things go wrong, it’s me that gets beaten by the local population because you cannot hit someone across the screen.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    That’s the basic idea.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see. This is a new portfolio that was created by the administration?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    It’s a new position, yeah. We always have horizontal ministers. It’s just a horizontal minister in charge of digital, that’s the new one.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We always have, for example, horizontal ministers in charge of law because each minister may pass their own laws and regulations, but someone needs to keep them coherent.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see. OK, good. You have a role in the science portfolio as well then. You tap into that?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Right. Basically, the staff, each of them when they join…I think you were a section chief?

    Link in context Link
  • Joel Chen

    Yes.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Right. I think Ning Yeh was Director-general, and so on. They all have their own network so to speak, yeah.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see, OK, all right, understood. Then, you report directly to the president or do you have…Are you a junior minister and you have…

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I’m working with the government. I’m not working for the government. I report to the Internet community.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, so you’re not actually an elected official, then.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I’m appointed.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see, OK, all right.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    So appointed by the president and confirmed by the premier.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I don’t have fixed constituents. My constituent is anyone who has an email account.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, gotcha. You’re not elected in that sense.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    No.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK. I didn’t…

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I’m not partisan either. That’s not an anomaly, though. In the cabinet, there’s more independent ministers than ministers belonging to any party.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Oh, OK. That’s quite different than Canada.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Indeed.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    And it’s a tradition in Taiwan to have this kind of positions?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yes. I think so because our design here is that the administration can propose draft bills; you don’t have to go through MPs to propose draft bills. The draft bills are of course subject to partisan fights among the amendments, but the skeleton of most bills are written and drafted by the administration, not by the parties.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Sure.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I think the importance here is that we are in the kind of neutral zone where the party politics are kind of at arm’s length. Then, we can consult meaningfully with people without as much party politics as they have in the legislation. Of course, they are free to act on our draft and do whatever.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    What are some of the achievements that have come out of your portfolio?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    One of it is co-creation of the important digital services that touches everybody like the tax filing experience, as well as mobile authentication to the universal healthcare system. The learnings from that effort will inform our plans next year to introduce a New eID.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We also work with the National Palace Museum – which is part of the cabinet because of an interesting history that goes back to the Qing Dynasty [laughs] – to co-design their ticketing systems. Their visitors may be 70 years old, may be 17 years old, and it’s a challenge to please those groups at the same time. We did a co-design workshop and there are still ongoing collaboration.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We worked with AIT a digital dialogue that invited both sites to communicate. Currently, our topic is security collaboration. There’s a lot of innovations in this field. Their first dialogue was how to promote Taiwan in the world. We came up with like the Presidential Hackathon and AIT should someone to the Presidential Hackathon, which they did, things like that.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Trade was the previous one. The next one is people do people, to be followed by AmCham’s consultation on talent circulation, I think. All this becomes kind of the norm for diplomacy to be public for everybody to participate meaningfully.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Have you engaged Sinica in some of these activities?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yes. Actually, we think of Academia Sinica as an important incubator of the g0v movement. The information science, the computer science department is where the bi-monthly hackathon happens. All the initiatives I mentioned actually have their prototype there. The previous head of the information science, computer science is now also advisor to the president on cyber security affairs, Dr. D. T. Lee.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    More broadly we consider Academia Sinica the incubator of Taiwan’s open source movement, and it’s home to many important infrastructure projects.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK. Then, are you also involved in this push to become more bilingual, if you will? That’s the focus of the government, I guess. Is that part of your strategy as well?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    There’s the bilingual, meaning that everything concerning foreign people need to be presented in also English. There’s also the National Languages Act, which means that for the different populations, if they want to learn physics or something, they can do it through materials in indigenous languages. Taiwan’s curriculum also takes into account people from Indonesia and Philippines and so on…

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    On this part is kind of a multi-ethnicity nation being built. On the other hand, there is English from the kindergarten level that’s being taught. Those are two strategies. I’m paying a lot of attention to enable them without wasting too much time on repetitive work, so mission translation and AI to speech and also mission translation transfer from one language to a near but lower resource language and so on. That is my field.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I worked with Apple on Siri for six years, so I help on that regard, but law making, that is the Ministry of Culture and the National Development Council respectively.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK. A lot of this is driven by AI, then, OK. Have you engaged much with the Canadian AI community on some of these issues?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yeah, on some issues, but I didn’t visit, what is it, the Direct Institute.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Oh, the Perimeter Institute?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    The Perimeter, yeah. I didn’t visit there. There’s quite a few AI startups being brought both ways between the two jurisdictions. I think one of the challenges also is bilingual AI in the public service for Canadians.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I think that is something that we should actually have more conversations about because when our conversation with AIT came, they care very much about the ex-pats being able to type their suggestions in English but also understanding the Mandarin speaking community’s voices.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right, or having websites where the translation is actually understandable, right?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    That’s right. It must not only be machine translation because it lost the nuances, right?

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    It turns out that so far, we’re using the AI software called Pol.is for this kind of conversation, very recently got this kind of bilingual capability sponsored by the Canadian government because of French, English. Then, we contribute on top of that. We’re already sharing the technical level AI components, but we’re not sharing on the policy level at this point.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, good. That’s interesting. What’s the future, then? Do you think this will continue if the government changes?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Certainly. I worked with the previous government, too.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Oh, OK. This was something that…

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yeah.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I started working with the public service end of 2014, and then as reverse mentor to Minister Jaclyn Tsai who’s the horizontal minister in charge of law. This is not a new thing in Taiwan and people actually competed on being more open.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    For example, in the DPP primary, William Lai’s platform was that like the President of Taiwan did great on open government, but he will be even more open.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK. That gives me a good feeling for…One of the big issues in trying to attract foreigners is the low salaries. Is there a strategy that the government is really working on to try to improve things? Are you a part of that?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    The what thing?

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Salaries, they’re so low here.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    The living expense is equally low though. If you translate to PPP, we’re doing very well.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, fair enough.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We’re trying to attract digital nomads for precisely this reason because they can earn a global salary, but they spend living expenses in Taiwan. That basically makes them twice as rich or thrice, actually.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, all right. You do have an active engagement of trying to recruit foreign talent?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We do. That’s why our Gold Card, unlike the Singapore one, is renewable. We want to attract as much digital nomads who are into hiking or surfing. I don’t care what attracts you. It could be food. You have property as a human right, so even if you hike to the top of the Jade Mountain, 4,000 meters almost, you have 10Mbps, you can work there. Well, maybe not for very long periods.

    Link in context Link
  • (laughter)

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    But that’s the idea, right?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    In any case, the idea is that you can continue to participate in the global ecosystem but having a separate place to live. That’s the idea. Then, once you renew your Gold Card for another term on the fifth year, you can become also Taiwanese. You don’t have to drop your original nationality.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right, OK. This is really something underpinning the whole government.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    That’s right, yeah. We want people to be also Taiwanese. We’re not saying that you need to convert to our nationality.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Excellent. What is your training, then? Are you trained as a physicist or a computer scientist?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I dropped out of junior high, so I’m self-educated.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Oh, really? OK.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I’m trained on Project Gutenberg and Arxiv.org.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, so you’re self-trained, then?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    That’s right. My main research topic is social interaction design. That’s basically building the first system like my startup back in ‘96 did the first B2C auction site in Taiwan, the first meta search engine, et cetera.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I quit that company and joined the Free Software movement, later on also advocated for Open Source, which now rejoined the Free Software Movement, and then it’s just social entrepreneurship after that. When I worked on my first startup, it’s not just computational linguistics, but also just social interaction design because nobody understands why people trust so much each other online in no time.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Yeah, that’s true.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Then, we really want to figure it out. That’s my main research interest, figuring out this.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see. How did you get into working with government, then?

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    We occupied the Parliament for 22 days.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Oh, so you were part of the…

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yeah, the Sunflower movement.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I see. That’s how you got the connection.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Yeah, because the MPs were on strike. The occupiers were just doing their job for them.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, interesting. Well, that was helpful. Thank you very much for your time. Nice to meet you. I forgot to give you my card.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I just printed a set of new cards. Feel free to have several because they also double as communication material. It’s interesting, because my name card is designed so that I’m not representing anyone.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Right, OK. The connection to the UN is for…

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    For the sustainable goals. That’s the 17 colors. I’m just saying Taiwan Can Help. This is lowercase digital minister meaning that I preach about digital transformation. All in all, this is an anarchist card signifying I’m working with, not for, the government.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, very good. Anyway, I just thought I’d introduce myself and learn more about you. Like I said, if there’s an option where I could help for something, don’t be shy about asking.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I’m sure that Joel will take you up on your offer. He’s our MOFA delegate. He’s in the foreign service, I’m just facilitating the space.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, very good. I won’t take anymore of your time.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Are you staying in Academia Sinica for a while?

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I’m moving here.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Oh, you are? That’s great.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    I’m the director of one of the institutes.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    I read about that, but I don’t realize that it’s permanent…

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Well, it is a permanent thing. I’m spending two years transitioning my research laboratory here, shutting down my operation in Edmonton. Then, I will be here until I retire.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    OK. Every other month, there will be a large event in your vicinity, the g0v Hackathon, so please just drop by and you’ll see the social innovation in action.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    OK, yeah. I’ll be in Taipei until I retire.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Excellent.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Yeah, good. OK, very good.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    See you around.

    Link in context Link
  • Dr. Todd Lowary

    Thanks for your time.

    Link in context Link
  • Audrey Tang

    Thank you.

    Link in context Link